
The Selection
Seasonal beers are my favorite way to get a good grasp on the versatility of craft breweries. It forces brewers to be creative in order to fully capture not only the perfect combination of Hops, Malts, Spices and Citrus but to match that combination with the season. I chose seven winter beers from breweries I was familiar with and decided to find my favorite. I think the key to a good winter seasonal is making a beer with the proper amount of spice and malts to keep you warm even when it’s enjoyed ice cold.
7. Lagunitas – Brown Shugga
Petaluma, CA
9.84% alcohol
I guess the sugar was too much for me, which landed this beer in the 7th spot. The high alcohol content wasn’t noticeable which could be a bonus to some, but I found the thick body and overpowering spice the downfall, it was hard to drink. Beer should always be refreshing even in the coldest of times.
6. Sierra Nevada – Celebration Ale
Chico, CA
6.8% alcohol
There was a unique hazy copper hue, and it showed this beer was less filtered than the others, there was a mild spice in it which pushes what would be a pale ale into something else. But for a celebration ale, this one didn’t really stand out like others, Sierra Nevada has been around for a long time but their seasonals still don’t do it for me.
5. Big Sky – Powder Hound
Missoula, Montana
6.2% alcohol
This was the hoppiest of all the beers I tried, it had a powerful hoppy aroma and a great amber coloring. While it tasted like an amber it had much more bite than normal, which can be good in winter ale’s , but I would have liked more malts in this one considering the heavy body.
4. Blue Moon – Full Moon
Golden, CO
5.6% alcohol
This beer was rated highest by my brother and Dad but the roasted malts and dark belgian sugar didn’t add enough holiday flavor for it to be my favorite. It reminded me of a light beer, a pilsner maybe, but it had darker coloring and a much fuller body. This would be the best choice if I was having a lot of them because it went down uncommonly smooth for a heavy beer.
3. Deschutes – Jubelale
Bend, OR
6.7% alcohol
I’ll be the first to admit that I’m a sucker for Deschutes, but their dark beers are so well done it’s just what I look for in a nice winter beeer. This beer had the darkest color and maltiest flavor but was still balanced enough to take third place, since it lacked that little something extra to set it apart from their usual brews.
2. New Belgium – 2° Below
Fort Collins, CO
6.6% alcohol
Copper hue with a piney aroma and wood flavored undertones, this sounds awkward but after a sip you’ll realize it’s subtle enough to work. Not too much hops or malt, but enough body to keep you warm. The dry hops are what I figure give this beer the unique woodlike flavor, and still very drinkable.
1. Anderson Valley – Winter Solstice
Boonville, CA
6.9% alcohol
Everything came together for this beer which is why I would rank it my favorite winter seasonal. It had a mild spice which I like in a winter seasonal but you only really picked up on it in the aftertaste. There was a nice hoppy aroma and Dark Amber color which excites your palate then it’s a smooth ride all the way till the finish. Easily the most drinkable beer I had of the night, it has just enough to keep you warm but not too overpowering in any way.

The Winner